what's 'wrong' with vignetting?

[craygc]

I think the vignetting adds to each of these photos except for the last one in fog. To me it detracts from what fog is all about: the pervasive uniformness.

Thanks John,

Just also to add on the "fog" one... thats not fog! The Pearl River Delta is at the centre of Chinese manufacturing. The province of Guangdong (behind Hong Kong) supports 10 of thousands of factories and the Pearl River is the path by which all this stuff comes to the world. The smog and pollution in this area is horrific and that is what soups up the air in that shot

 

[noimmunity]

Hey Joe, the ZM C Biogon 35/2.8 has a touch of vignetting wide open that I found very pleasing.