f16sunshine
Moderator
Was not even thinking if they were "good" or "positive," irrelevant to my point. I don't personally like the approach especially among amateurs. You were of course invited.
I think the idea of the thread is to practice giving and receiving "critique" rather than simply back patting or remaining silent.
An exercise from both sides.
It's not an academic setting or even one where all involved are qualified. That's not the point (my view anyway).
The point is more to try and be constructive.
With online boards everyone is an amateur.
Some pros may be cooler headed if they remembered that! 🙂