what do you want rff to be?

let's have a real discussion about rff.
what do you want it to be?

there are complaints that it's a gear site, complaints that it's not about photography...people want to discuss politics here...want to insult the jews and other ethnic groups...want to vent about flickr and call each other nasty names...

what do you want?

I think we need more camera bag theads,
but have not found anyone that interested in them.

Stephen
 
One thing I'm very hot on is fractious individuals who seem to enjoy making combative, sarcastic posts.

There are a couple of notables around at the moment and I really don't get it ... what do you get from it?
 
One thing I'm very hot on is fractious individuals who seem to enjoy making combative, sarcastic posts.

There are a couple of notables around at the moment and I really don't get it ... what do you get from it?

Attention, like an obnoxious child scribbling on the walls, testing what will you do about it.
 
Largely depends on what you call "politics". The definition of that word varies a lot depending on locations. And RFF is an international worldwide forum. You say "politics", I say "social problems", and so on...

I have not read the Turkish protests thread (nor do I know in which subforum it is hidden) but I was seeing no reason to delete the Thatcher's funeral photos thread. What Maggie Thatcher did now belongs to documented history and it seems legit to me that people having suffered from her terrible policy can discuss this while looking at her (funded with public GBPs) funeral photos. And the photos Simon posted are very good, photographically wise...

Gosh ! I just made you hear my own "opinion on politics"... ;)

But, some people think her policies were correct, so that is the source of the problem. Those of us not in lockstep with Labour Party or Progressive ideology get slammed almost in every thread where the politics gets discussed. I prefer to say a person is misguided than call them evil or stupid, and I apologize to the OP in that thread for going off topic. And yeah, I am a hothead.... and I've been insulted personally at times over the years, but the mods do a good job cleaning up the broken bar furniture...

As a conservative I feel like a turd in the punch bowl around here a large portion of the time, and conservatives buy bags and rangefinders just like the progressives and socialists...
 
Last edited:
Gear and photography go together to some degree. I don't mind a little gear talk, especially when members help others solving gear problems. The occasional [insert camera brand] p*rn thread is o.k. too.

People have the ability to choose what threads to read, so there should be no reason to say "There is too much gear talk." Don't participate if you don't like it. Start your own photography thread. Just respect others wishes. If a member starts a photography thread, then don't talk about gear other than providing information that helps the thread.

Politics should stick to documentation of a political situation, or discussions about politics affecting photography. The same for religion. We are a large community with different points of view and leaving politics and religious beliefs out of the discussions will go a long way towards community harmony.
 
As for politics ... I can live without having to deal with that stuff here ... it's everywhere else and little is achieved by hammering it within a camera/photography forum.

That's my view also, until someone hacks me off.

And yeah,I am aware that I lack class and show boorish behavior when hacked off.
 
I like to read about gear. I used to read the original Cameraquest pages when there was very little else online about old cameras.

When I bought something I wanted to research many years ago, the search engines referred me to RFF, which is how I found out about it.

I must say, in the early days of RFF, there were many more really knowledgable people with real in-depth information about esoteric gear. I wish there was more of it now.

I find nothing wrong with being a gear-head camera collector. There is no crime in really liking to buy cameras and lenses, and not really being a "great artist". Most people can't be.
 
Think that is pretty well said Al. Live and let live is the way I try to live. Maybe I have a simplistic view on life but I would rather concentrate on my life rather than try to convince someone that I am right and they are wrong. Agree also with Keith, there are a few here that like a fight. I am here because it relaxes me and there are so many more people here know what I am am trying to learn.
 
... We are a large community with different points of view and leaving politics and religious beliefs out of the discussions will go a long way towards community harmony.

These two topics by itself are covering 90% [rough guess ] of evil deeds between people in the world, let's not have these infect our little community. A big +1

...

there are complaints that it's a gear site, complaints that it's not about photography...people want to discuss politics here...want to insult the jews and other ethnic groups...want to vent about flickr and call each other nasty names...
...

Positively this attitude has no place here.

There are forum sections for gear and sections for dicussion about what you can actually produce when using it. As always, buying a tool is much easier than using it and producing a result you are proud of the share and ask for feedback.

This might be an obvious explantion why there is more talk abut gear than about photography but everyone is free to choose what to read and where to contribute.

I value a lot of the technical input that is being shared here and I also like the gallery "pick of the week" threads. The "Monochrome best pics" thread has accumulated a lot of stunning photographs and attracted a lot of views but more importantly it has been a free of any p...ing contest attitude, as far as I can tell.
I like this place ;).
 
let's have a real discussion about rff.
what do you want it to be?

there are complaints that it's a gear site, complaints that it's not about photography...people want to discuss politics here...want to insult the jews and other ethnic groups...want to vent about flickr and call each other nasty names...

what do you want?
All the above:D;) Except the name calling, thats not cool.
 
Seems to Me An Overall Great Site :D
Eclectic Mix of People & Viewpoints
Jaw dropping photography
What more could you Want...

If we have to start thinking about it...wer'e in Trouble :eek:
 
Helen--couldn't agree more!
Stop thinking and just enjoy.
And let you moderators take care of the crazies...:)
Thanks! And I love your photos...
Paul
 
I'd like to list just a few of the hundreds of things that make this a great site. Fell free to add lots more.

Chris Crawford's pictures, and all the help he gives.

Tom A, for his knowledge, help, entertaining comments, and his sense of humor.

Back Alley Joe for his inexhaustible range of interests: bags; practically every new digital camera from the Epson R-D1 forward; endless ideas for new thread topics (watches, knives, etc.)

New thread topics like watches, knives, and stuff.

Raid, for all he contributes

Helen, for all she contributes

Keith, for all he contributes

Roger Hicks for all the time and energy he puts in here, even though he has many other things to do.

Bill Pierce, for sharing his thoughts with us.

I think it's the people that make this forum what it is.

It's about rangefinders and photography with rangefinders.

It's about SLRs, DSLRs; tiny digital cameras; and photography with those.

And a lot of gear talk we use to distract ourselves from everyday ennui.

It's a community, that's what.

I would not change a thing. It's as close as anything will ever get to being all things to all people.
 
Well FWIW, I keep coming back - so that should mean something :)
I do believe a vast majority likes RFF just the way it is, and I'm one of them.

One thing that bugs me (and this plagues all forums too btw) is sustained off-topic posts that diverge from the spirit of the OP.
I have no qualms about civil political dialogue as long as the thread title and OP reflect this.
 
Seems to Me An Overall Great Site :D
Eclectic Mix of People & Viewpoints
Jaw dropping photography
What more could you Want...

If we have to start thinking about it...wer'e in Trouble :eek:

Exactally. & thus far this thread here is how a political discussion (with photo's) should be. This Helen reminds me so much of the OWS photo's Eric shot over on flickr. Eric showed me how much our US News was so full of lies & propaganda. I hope this kind of documentation of happenings around the world never disappear from RFF.
 
Exactally. & thus far this thread here is how a political discussion (with photo's) should be. This Helen reminds me so much of the OWS photo's Eric shot over on flickr. Eric showed me how much our US News was so full of lies & propaganda. I hope this kind of documentation of happenings around the world never disappear from RFF.

Looked like a good thread, but I can't see the photos as wifi here is slow again...
 
Diversity is good.

Tolerance is good.

Learning from others is good.

Helping others learn is good.

All of these thing are a part of RFF.

Since I first visited here late in 2005 the pace of change throughout the field of photogaphy has constantly accelerated. We RFF members have helped each other deal with the impact of the turbulence. This is also good.
 
am preferring to read and discuss about new or new-old gear only, as it usually stays on topic. e.g. technical facts are less debatable or subject to personal tastes. dont want to sound like a jerk but am not respecting anonymous opinions about photography/design/styles/etc much, and am trying not to offer those as anonymous either.

talk politics? why not in separate section, as long as it stays there and does not flood the front page for instance.
 
People are usually polite and "self-moderated" when they meet face to face.
Put them under the anonymity of a car, or a web forum, and they can behave in the craziest way, and the level of fine tuned communication offered from a car or a web talk is very low.
So, just as I wouldn't like my roads to be without laws and a good law enforcement system, I'm happy that RFF has "safety measures" to avoid inevitable crashes, and an active moderation.

No tolerance to intolerance.
 
Back
Top Bottom